Here's the list of flavors I purchased at Galco's:
Dr. Pepper - Original Formula
Manhattan Special: Vanilla Cream, Special Black Cherry, Orange Soda, Espresso Coffee, Sarsaparilla
Bana-Nina (Banana flavor)
Cheerwine
Jeff's Egg Cream - Chocolate, Orange Dream
Double Cola
Sweet Blossom Soda - Rose
Stewart's Key Lime
Moxie Original Elixir
Sioux City Sarsaparilla
Apple-Beer
NuGrape
Dad's Root Beer
So far I have tried the Stewart's Key Lime and the Dr. Pepper - Original Formula. The key lime was intensely sweet whereas the Dr. Pepper was great. The next flavors I plan on trying are the Manhattan Special Orange Soda, Espresso Coffee and Double Cola.
I try to keep my soda consumption down to one every couple of days, but I will post reviews of the different flavors as I try them.