I remember Curtis posting a reproduction process involving variable drills, swirling and sanding. Is that what you did?
I do want to experiment with colored resins, create a mold, eight actually, mix the base color and swirl in white or some other color and pour the resin mix into the molds. This would get very close to the originals...
Mine are just powder-coated red. I powder-coated all the shelves, product display and brackets, the red trim around the mirror, and the black base is also powder-coated since this woud hold up to foot traffic better.