Title: Krylon vs. rustoleum 2nd month summary
Post by: joesquid on August 10, 2005, 06:17:00 pm
Howdy all,
Man where did this month go? Seems like I just did the first month post last week! I don't have pics this month, wife took the digital camera with her and the kids to the in-laws (vacation). Great part is I now have tons of free time to work on machines!
Last month I noted that the krylon shelves were already oxidizing and the rustoleum shelves had no apparent wear. After anonther month of use the oxidatin on the krylon shelves appears to have slowed considerably. There's very little change between this month and last month. The krylon paint no longer comes off on the fingers or on a rag as it did last month. Appearance of the krylon has dulled some but not nearly as much as it did in the first month. Bottom line: it still appears duller than the rustoleum and any and all "discrepancies" (i.e. scratches, pits, etc) covered by the paint show up very plainly.
The rustoleum still shows no wear and is as bright and shiny as the day I sprayed it. If I hadn't marked the unfinished and finished shelves, I would have no idea which is which.
In the last month the products on the shelves were swapped such that shelves previously carrying glass products next carried plastic and vice versa. For the next month, the products will be switched back.
So far rustoleum is well ahead in this comparison. I'll post pics next month. For anyone just reading this thread for the first time, this is a six month wear test of Rustoleum Hammertone Silver vs. Krylon Rust Tough Battleship Gray. The initial thread is here: rustoleum vs. krylon wear test proposal
First Month Results: krylon vs. rustoleum first month test results
Man where did this month go? Seems like I just did the first month post last week! I don't have pics this month, wife took the digital camera with her and the kids to the in-laws (vacation). Great part is I now have tons of free time to work on machines!
Last month I noted that the krylon shelves were already oxidizing and the rustoleum shelves had no apparent wear. After anonther month of use the oxidatin on the krylon shelves appears to have slowed considerably. There's very little change between this month and last month. The krylon paint no longer comes off on the fingers or on a rag as it did last month. Appearance of the krylon has dulled some but not nearly as much as it did in the first month. Bottom line: it still appears duller than the rustoleum and any and all "discrepancies" (i.e. scratches, pits, etc) covered by the paint show up very plainly.
The rustoleum still shows no wear and is as bright and shiny as the day I sprayed it. If I hadn't marked the unfinished and finished shelves, I would have no idea which is which.
In the last month the products on the shelves were swapped such that shelves previously carrying glass products next carried plastic and vice versa. For the next month, the products will be switched back.
So far rustoleum is well ahead in this comparison. I'll post pics next month. For anyone just reading this thread for the first time, this is a six month wear test of Rustoleum Hammertone Silver vs. Krylon Rust Tough Battleship Gray. The initial thread is here: rustoleum vs. krylon wear test proposal
First Month Results: krylon vs. rustoleum first month test results
Title: Krylon vs. rustoleum 2nd month summary
Post by: jasmine64 on August 10, 2005, 07:24:56 pm
Eric,
This is good to know. I have been debating on what to use on my Cavailer. Needs a little something more than cleaning, but was unsure what to go with.
I'll keep following your post and decide on your findings.
Oh yeah, I'm making that trip to Destin in Nov!!!
Want me to send your reguards?
This is good to know. I have been debating on what to use on my Cavailer. Needs a little something more than cleaning, but was unsure what to go with.
I'll keep following your post and decide on your findings.
Oh yeah, I'm making that trip to Destin in Nov!!!
Want me to send your reguards?
Title: Krylon vs. rustoleum 2nd month summary
Post by: joesquid on August 10, 2005, 07:32:54 pm
Jasmine,
By all means, please tell him howdy. We stay in touch anyway but it'll be a nice surprise for him coming from someone else.
Eric
By all means, please tell him howdy. We stay in touch anyway but it'll be a nice surprise for him coming from someone else.
Eric
Title: Krylon vs. rustoleum 2nd month summary
Post by: jasmine64 on August 10, 2005, 07:37:27 pm
Will do!
Title: Krylon vs. rustoleum 2nd month summary
Post by: BryanH on August 10, 2005, 10:48:14 pm
Eric - you are thorough....
Title: Krylon vs. rustoleum 2nd month summary
Post by: Eric on August 11, 2005, 07:12:12 am
This will determine what I use on my 56....
Thanks for doing this and sharing the results.
Eric
Thanks for doing this and sharing the results.
Eric
Title: Krylon vs. rustoleum 2nd month summary
Post by: on August 11, 2005, 08:58:24 am
Thank you for sharing the results. This makes the decision of what to use much easier. 
Title: Krylon vs. rustoleum 2nd month summary
Post by: joesquid on August 13, 2005, 10:52:50 pm
Thanks for the votes of confidence. It's just nice to finally be able to provide some useful information. I feel like I ask more questions than I answer, so just wanted to find a way to give back a little. Honestly, I'm depressed at the results so far. I was hoping the Krylon would hold up as well in a cold environment. I like the hammertone, but was hoping to find something that would look closer to nickel plating without the cost and would hold up as well. But then it's also fun to put my labrat brain to work! 
Title: Krylon vs. rustoleum 2nd month summary
Post by: dprat1 on August 15, 2005, 02:50:06 pm
I hope the Rustoleum Hammer wins cause I have already completed interior with it. I was confident with the product. I had previously used it on the wheel rims for my ATV. It has held up beautifully under extreme conditions.
Doug
Doug
Title: Krylon vs. rustoleum 2nd month summary
Post by: Eric on August 15, 2005, 03:55:26 pm
I have a friend who painted his truck bed with black hammertone. Has hauled off brush & wood
and it has held up pretty good... And all mine is gonna do is use on the interior of a soda machine...
I think I'm gonna go with the Hammertone on my 56 & 39 interior......
Eric
and it has held up pretty good... And all mine is gonna do is use on the interior of a soda machine...
I think I'm gonna go with the Hammertone on my 56 & 39 interior......
Eric
Title: Krylon vs. rustoleum 2nd month summary
Post by: BryanH on August 15, 2005, 06:20:19 pm
| Quote (dprat1 @ Aug. 15 2005,12:50) |
| I hope the Rustoleum Hammer wins cause I have already completed interior with it. I was confident with the product. I had previously used it on the wheel rims for my ATV. It has held up beautifully under extreme conditions. Doug |
Doug - don't think there's much too worry about. Between Eric's 2 month report and the past experience of others its certainly durable. I used Hammerite rather than Rustoleum (Eric here's a matchup for your next test....) and I painted all my metal parts (I mean ALL) except the captive link mechanism parts in the vending assembly. Will do those parts on my next machine.... Just didn't do it on this (first) machine as I didn't know how thick it went on and wasn't sure what the tolerances were for the link mechs.
Title: Krylon vs. rustoleum 2nd month summary
Post by: joesquid on August 18, 2005, 12:31:02 pm
That's not a bad idea. A True Value nearby me (in Bath) carries hammerite. And I've got four untreated shelves in the same machine I'm using for the rustoleum/krylon test. Hmmmmm....it'll have to wait until September as I'll be leaving for Norfolk, VA tomorrow to get my eyes fixed (PRK surgery) and also picking up a WC-44SK on the way!!! So if worse comes to worse and I come back blind, I'll just have my wife paint the shelves for me!! 
Title: Krylon vs. rustoleum 2nd month summary
Post by: BryanH on August 18, 2005, 06:08:41 pm
Good luck with the surgery.... We'll see you when you get back.